Quick answer
A standby generator runs for days on natural gas and can carry a whole house, but it costs about $7,000 to $15,000 installed, earns no rebate and saves nothing between outages. A battery is quiet, needs no fuel and earns about $300/kWh from ComEd or Ameren, but runs for hours, not days, unless solar recharges it. Many homes pair a battery with solar for everyday savings.
How do a generator and a battery compare?
| Standby generator (about 24 kW) | Home battery (13.5 kWh, e.g., Powerwall 3) | |
|---|---|---|
| Installed cost | About $7,000 to $15,000 | Varies by installer; get it itemized |
| Illinois rebate | None | About $4,050 per battery from ComEd or Ameren |
| Runs on | Natural gas or propane | Stored electricity, recharged by solar or the grid |
| How long it lasts | Days, as long as fuel flows | Hours to a day or more, longer with solar recharging |
| Power at once | Can start central air and large appliances | 11.5 kW continuous per Powerwall 3; more with two |
| Noise | About 67 dB at 23 feet when running | Silent |
| Maintenance | Oil and filter every 200 hours or 2 years, annual service | Little to none |
| Saves money day to day | No | Yes, by storing solar and through the utility's virtual power plant |
A battery also has to be enrolled in the utility's virtual power plant program to get the rebate, so the utility can draw on it at set summer peak times. See whole-home battery backup.
How long do power outages last in Illinois?
Usually not long. The U.S. Energy Information Administration lists Illinois among the states whose customers averaged less than one power interruption in 2024. ComEd reported Chicago customers averaged 28 minutes without power in 2025, and that more than 99% of customers affected by outages were restored within 48 hours.
- August 2020 derecho: more than 635,000 ComEd customers lost power, and about 200,000 were still out two days later.
- July 2023 storms: more than 225,000 Ameren Illinois customers were interrupted over three days.
- July 15, 2024 storms: more than 440,000 ComEd customers lost power after a line of storms and tornadoes; about 82,000 were still out two days later.
So the real question is how long your worst outage could last. A battery handles the typical short outage well; multi-day storm outages are where a generator, or a battery with enough solar to recharge, earns its keep.
How much fuel does a standby generator use?
| Generator | Natural gas, half load | Natural gas, full load | Propane, full load |
|---|---|---|---|
| Generac Guardian 24 kW | About 205 cubic feet per hour | About 306 cubic feet per hour | About 3.9 gallons per hour |
| Kohler 26RCAL | About 180 cubic feet per hour | About 290 cubic feet per hour | About 129 cubic feet of vapor per hour |
On propane, a 500-gallon tank holds about 400 usable gallons because tanks are filled to 80%. At a half-load burn of about 2.53 gallons an hour, that's roughly 6.6 days of nonstop running, and deliveries can be slow after a big storm. Natural gas has no tank to run dry, so it is the usual choice where a gas line is available.
Where can a standby generator go, and what does it need?
National fire code rules followed by generator makers require at least 5 feet between the generator and any window, door or vent, plus 5 feet of clearance above it. Many Illinois villages add their own rules: Lincolnwood, for example, allows generators only in rear yards and at least 20 feet from a neighbor's window, and Northbrook requires a plat of survey and an electrical permit.
Generators also need a gas line sized for full load, an automatic transfer switch, and regular care: Generac calls for an oil and filter change every 200 hours of running or at least every two years, and more often in extreme temperatures. They run a short self-test each week, at about 57 dB, quieter than the roughly 67 dB of full operation.
Can a battery replace a standby generator?
For most outages, yes. One 13.5 kWh battery can run the essentials for about a day, and solar panels can recharge it on sunny days, which can stretch backup indefinitely in summer. Whole-home backup with central air usually takes two or more batteries. Batteries can lose some output in very cold weather; Generac's PWRcell 2 spec sheet, for example, notes reduced output below 32°F.
Where a battery falls short is a long winter outage with heavy loads like electric heat. If that's your main worry, a generator, or both, makes more sense.
Can I use a generator and a battery together?
Yes. Some homes use the battery for short outages and everyday solar savings, with a generator as a last resort for long ones. They connect through a transfer switch and usually work as separate layers: Tesla notes, for example, that Powerwall doesn't recharge from a generator. Ask an installer to design both together so the switching is automatic.
Whatever you choose, never run a portable generator indoors or in a garage. The Consumer Product Safety Commission linked portable generators to an estimated 765 carbon monoxide deaths from 2009 through 2019.
Sources
- PowerOutage.us: Whole-house generator cost installed (2025)
- Build.com: Generac Guardian 24 kW (7210) specifications
- Kohler: 26RCAL residential generator spec sheet
- Generac: How much fuel does my home standby generator use?
- Generac: Yearly maintenance for home standby generators
- Generac: Clearance requirements when installing a generator
- Village of Lincolnwood: Generator handout
- Village of Northbrook: Single-family generator permit requirements
- U.S. EIA: U.S. electricity customers averaged about 11 hours of power interruptions in 2024
- T&D World: ComEd reports 2025 operational milestones
- WTTW: Tens of thousands still without power after derecho (August 2020)
- Ameren Illinois: Power restoration update (July 2023)
- ComEd: Power restored for more than 350,000 customers after extreme storms (July 2024)
- Tesla: Powerwall 3 installation manual, specifications
- Generac: PWRcell 2 battery spec sheet
- Tesla: Combining Powerwall with a generator
- ComEd: Distributed generation and storage rebates
- Ameren Illinois: DER Bulletin 2026-04 (storage rebate and virtual power plant)
- U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission: Carbon monoxide deaths associated with consumer products (2023 report)
This guide is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice. Incentive programs change, so confirm current terms with your installer, your utility and a tax professional.
